Building Resilience or Manufacturing Anxiety?

Picture of Brian Reverman

Brian Reverman

Visiting artist - Educational consultant

Every international school I’ve worked in wants to build students that have a growth mindset, and the ability to handle setbacks. I believe in the goal. What I keep noticing, as both a teacher inside these schools and a parent whose kids came through them, is a gap between what the mission claims to build and what the system around it produces.

My own kids are in their twenties now, several years out of international school. Most of their close friends from that world carry some version of anxiety they didn’t have as children. That’s not a study. It’s not even a claim about causation I can defend rigorously; a lot changed for that cohort between adolescence and now, and I can’t isolate school from everything else. But it’s a pattern consistent enough, across enough kids I watched grow up, that I don’t think it’s coincidence, and I don’t think naming it plainly requires more proof than that.

Some of what’s happening isn’t the school’s fault at all. Kids today measure themselves against a curated highlight reel of the entire planet, not just their own grade. Not being a self-made YouTube millionaire by sixteen can register as failure when the comparison set is every teenager on Earth who’s ever gone viral, rather than the twenty other kids in their classroom. And the news cycle that reaches them isn’t calibrated for a developing nervous system; a feed that’s mostly crisis, mostly conflict, mostly the worst thing that happened today somewhere on the planet, will produce a distorted sense of how dangerous the world actually is, regardless of what any individual school does about it. When you walk by the counseling office, it is always full.

But schools aren’t just bystanders to that environment. I’ve written before about how the credentialing race turns school into a place where students learn to chase rank rather than build competence, and about the specific ways a high-stakes, one-shot grading culture punishes exactly the kind of risk-taking a resilience-focused mission claims to want. Both of those pressures are still doing their work here; I won’t rebuild the arguments, but they’re part of the mechanism, not separate from it.

Here’s the version of the mechanism that’s specific to resilience language, though. The competition many of these students are in isn’t for something that expands when more people succeed. Economist Fred Hirsch named this decades ago: a positional good gets its value from relative scarcity, from being something not everyone can have, rather than from its own quality. He named elite education specifically as an example. A spot at a small number of highly selective universities doesn’t grow because more sixteen-year-olds work harder for it. If every applicant in a cohort doubled their effort overnight, the number of spots at Stanford wouldn’t change, and neither would the odds. Telling a student anxious about that competition to simply build more grit is asking them to out-effort a fixed supply. That’s not resilience training. That’s asking a kid to feel less bad about a race that was rigged by arithmetic before they entered it.

Parents make this worse, and I say that as one who passes on my fair share of anxiety to my kids, not as an outside critic. When you’re paying international-school tuition, it’s natural to want a visible, legible return, and the most visible return available is the acceptance letter. A parent hovering over every assignment, managing every setback before the student must, isn’t doing that out of a failure of love; it’s usually the opposite. In fact, it’s what maximum love looks like when the perceived stakes are a fixed, scarce outcome rather than a range of decent ones. But a student who’s never allowed to fail small can’t build the capacity to survive failing large, and a parent optimizing hardest for the acceptance letter is often, without meaning to, optimizing directly against the resilience the school claims to be building. As a teacher it was easy to tell another parent that their child was going to be OK, but when I heard that from my kids’ teachers it was harder to feel reassured.

None of this means the outlook is bleak, and I don’t want to leave it there, because there is a trend that gives me hope. My own kids, and a lot of their friends, also see something real happening in the world that doesn’t make it into the anxiety-inducing feed: people building things that aren’t zero-sum, mutual aid networks, worker-owned cooperatives, local projects that don’t depend on beating anyone else to a fixed prize. I’m not going to make a grand claim about capitalism ending or a new economic era arriving; that’s a bigger argument than I’m equipped to make here, and I’d be overreaching if I tried. What I can say is narrower: my kids’ generation seems to be building a working knowledge that the zero-sum framing they were raised inside isn’t the only available one, even if the schools that raised them mostly taught the zero-sum version by default.

I don’t think the fix is dropping resilience from the mission statement. Michael Apple’s work on the hidden curriculum names the actual mechanism here: schools teach real lessons through their daily structure, ranking, single-shot high-stakes assessment, competition for scarce credentials, regardless of what the mission statement says they value. A school can print resilience on page one of its handbook and teach competition and risk-aversion in every other page of how it runs. The fix isn’t better language. It’s being honest about which parts of a school’s structure are quietly teaching the opposite of what the mission claims, and which parts are just the ambient noise of the world these kids happen to be growing up in. Those require different fixes, and right now most schools, mine included at various points, treat them as the same problem.

error: Content is protected !!